
This banter immediately sparked backlash on the internet. Commenters on Reddit labeled the quip “inappropriate” and in “bad taste,” pointing out that making light of an actual homicide was disrespectful to the victims and their loved ones. “They really should have cut that part out — Ryan shouldn’t have mentioned it at all,” one viewer stated. Others echoed this sentiment, pointing out that treating true crime tragedies merely as amusement crosses a boundary.
Still, not every viewer took offense. Several fans advised against making a mountain out of a molehill, reminding people that it was just a playful interaction on a television game show.

Robin proceeded to triumph in her Bonus Round by solving the puzzle “He is Beaming With Joy,” taking home an extra $45,000. This brought her spectacular grand total for the evening to $66,050.
This broadcast highlighted how a wholesome family program can ignite controversy when delicate subjects intersect with television banter.